Wednesday, March 12, 2025

THE STORIES BEHIND THE SONGS

The True Story Behind THE BEACH BOYS'Classic Song "THE WARMTH OF THE SUN"

 

Some forty years from now, our children will pause for a moment on September 11th and reflect on the events of that day back in 2001 when a blatant attack on our soil leveled The Twin Towers in New York City. The most popular topic of discussion that far off day will most likely be “Where were you when the second tower fell?” and friends and family of that generation will share a memory or two of where they were the moment they first realized what had actually happened on that fateful day. (With a little luck, most of the troops stationed overseas ever since will also be home with their families by then, too!) 

 

If you were part of the original Beach Boys Generation, your emotionally scarring tell-tale target date is November 22, 1963 … the day that President John Fitzgerald Kennedy was shot and killed in the motorcade making its way through Dealy Plaza in Dallas, Texas. Where WE were that day when we first heard the news has been forever emblazoned in our minds.

 

You would think that this would be the case for any American old enough to comprehend the events of that day … but we’ve found that, while pretty much everybody in The Beach Boys’ camp agrees that their beautiful ballad, ‘The Warmth Of The Sun’, was somehow inspired and / or completed around the events of that day, they all seem to have slightly different recollections surrounding the circumstances of writing this beautiful song. In fact, man for man, they each seem to tell a slightly different story … and, in some case, the same participant has varied their story over the years.

 

Today, on the anniversary of that fateful day in Dallas, we’ll try to sort out what we know and then leave you to draw your own conclusions.

 

***

 

Recently, a team of experts selected by Chicago's Museum of Broadcast Communications (who celebrated their 25th anniversary this past year) decided that: "Reports of the assassination and funeral of President John F. Kennedy in 1963” tops the list of the ‘most memorable’ political moments in American radio and television history. This elite group compiled the list of the 125 most unforgettable political moments since radio's debut on Election Night 1920. The events of Sept. 11, 2001, ranked second, and the first presidential debate between Kennedy and Richard M. Nixon in 1960 ranked third.

For years, published reports (based on interviews with the song’s co-writers, Brian Wilson and Mike Love), have documented that this song was written during the hours surrounding The Kennedy Assassination. Reportedly, in a moment of grief after the assassination of President Kennedy, collaborators Brian Wilson and Mike Love locked themselves in the recording studio that same evening and poured all of their heartfelt emotion into the writing of this song. Wilson said that they were trying to evoke a feeling of a happier time and place ... and ‘The Warmth of the Sun’ not only achieves that goal but also maintains The Beach Boys’ ties to the surfing phenomenon that launched their career in the first place. That brief synopsis (along with the news of The Museum of Broadcast Communications poll) first appeared in our Forgotten Hits Newsletter back on November 22, 2007, along with a couple of quotes from Brian Wilson to substantiate this claim.

We were immediately besieged with alternate versions of the story … some by folks who were there at the time and some who had heard things differently over the years by way of interviews with the two key players, Brian Wilson and Mike Love.

 

Noted Rock and Roll Photographer Michael Bush, who has spent a fair amount of time in the touring company of The Beach Boys told us:

 

“’The Warmth of the Sun’ was written the night before JFK was assassinated. I’ve spent a lot of time with The Beach Boys over the years and I’ve heard Mike (Love) tell this story more than once. He says there was a melancholy feeling in the air when they were writing and finding out about JFK the morning after they wrote it kind of freaked them out!”

 

Fred Vail, who at the time was The Beach Boys’ concert promoter and advance man, had a different version of the story to share:

 

“We played a show in Marysville, California, that evening and, after we drove back to the El Dorado Hotel in Sacramento, some fifty miles away, Brian and Mike wrote ‘Warmth of the Sun.’”

 

In fact, Fred has long documented this story on his website: http://denniswilsonforever.wg-net.com/fred.html

 

He even has a copy of the original tour poster promoting that show on that date for view on this site. (We’ve included it at the end of this article as well.) If this is true, Mike and Brian did not meet up at the studio … or Brian’s office that evening to work on the song … they were hundreds of miles away on tour at the time!

 

So I decided to dig a little deeper to see if we could find anything that would corroborate any version of these stories.

 

Starting with commentary made by Brian in various CD booklets, interviews and his own biography, I found that, in virtually every source where this song's origins were documented and discussed, it was always attributed to having been written after the Kennedy assassination … when both Mike and Brian were feeling completely distraught … as was the rest of the nation! (The big difference, of course, was the fact that these guys had the talent to express their feelings in a much more melodic way!!!)

 

In his own (albeit ghost-written) autobiography, Brian says:

 

"In November, the day after John F. Kennedy was assassinated, Mike and I got together and wrote 'The Warmth Of The Sun,' a plaintive melancholy ballad that expressed our sentiments, beginning 'What good is the dawn that grows into day? The sunset at night or living this way?'"

 

(The way I seem to remember the story most often being told is that Brian and Mike were SO bummed out over the events of the day that they just went to the studio that night … or, in some publications, Brian’s office … just to hang out, not even thinking about writing or recording anything. They were too overcome with grief and disbelief over the tragic events in Dallas that afternoon. Feeling very melancholy, the sadness came out in what eventually became ‘The Warmth of the Sun’, one of their prettiest and most heartfelt ballads.)

 

In the self-penned liner notes to The Beach Boys Classics CD (songs selected by Brian Wilson himself), Brian writes:

 

"I wrote this in honor of President John F. Kennedy. He was assassinated on November 22nd, 1963 and that night, Mike and I got together at my office in Hollywood and wrote the song."

 

In the liner notes to the Shut Down, Volume 2 CD, Wilson wrote:

 

"The day after President Kennedy was assassinated, Mike and I went to my office in Hollywood and wrote 'The Warmth of the Sun' at my piano. We knew that we had a spiritual song on our hands and we recorded it with that kind of attitude." 

 

In the liner notes for the same CD, noted Beach Boys Historian David Leaf writes:

 

"The song was written on November 23, 1963, only hours after President John F. Kennedy was assassinated. Brian had just broken up with his first serious girlfriend. This melancholy ballad and beautiful lyric perfectly capture that feeling of loss. He clearly feels the pain but he is at peace."

 

During a special podcast broadcast during the summer of last year, Brian again recalled the significance of this beautiful ballad, although this time he spoke more of the beauty of the song than any inspiring circumstances:

 

"When I listen to 'The Warmth of the Sun' I ask myself, ‘How the hell did I sing so sweetly?’ I get real, real good memories about writing 'The Warmth of the Sun.' It took Mike and I 45 minutes to write that song. That's how fast we worked. Some of the best songs come pretty quick; they're the most divinely-inspired songs."

 

In an interview with Endless Summer Quarterly late last year, Mike Love remembered it this way:

 

"’The Warmth of the Sun' was a very mystical experience. Brian and I were actually writing that (song) the night before President Kennedy was assassinated, so it was November, 1963. Brian and I were at a rented house in Hawthorne, CA. He had moved out of his family place because (his father) Murry was just too much to deal with. I'd gone over and spent the night there. Around 11 PM or midnight we were writing this song, and Brian had this beautifully haunting melody going. I just related the loss of someone you love. I wrote the words accordingly. There was a very mystical eerie feeling associated with writing the song before we went to sleep. The next morning we woke-up and we heard that President Kennedy had been shot (and of course, later we heard that he had been assassinated). "When we recorded the song a few days later it had quite an eerie, mystical and moody feeling attached to it (and it always has) for me. It has that haunting melancholy to it. Brian has always had that melancholy side in his nature and I've always had the more positive approach (lyrically) to things to counter-balance his melancholy. In the case of 'The Warmth of the Sun,' you have the melody and the harmonies, but the lyrics 'still I have the warmth of the sun within me tonight.' In other words, even though it was a negative or hurtful experience, you still came out of it with something good or positive. I was trying (in my own way) to stay true to the feeling and the mood of the song, but also give it some sort of salvation in that there was some thing good that came out of the experience even though it was hurtful."

 

Here is where some of this story starts to fall apart. While it’s entirely possibly (maybe even likely) that Brian already had some type of melody working in his head … (let’s face it … it wasn’t at ALL uncommon for The Beach Boys to rework the same melody into different songs during the early years!) … and just as likely that ‘The Warmth Of The Sun’ was not completed in one sitting (although Brian himself just told us a moment ago that the song took all of 45 minutes to complete) … the circumstances as described by both Mike and Brian don’t hold water when you consider the fact that The Beach Boys were out on the road at the time … and, in fact, played a concert performance in Marysville, California on the evening of the assassination! Now I suppose that it's entirely possible that Mike and Brian woke up to the news of President Kennedy’s assassination ... as I recall, he was officially pronounced dead at 1 PM Chicago Time ... when you factor in the time change, it's probably more likely than not that these rock and rollers wouldn't have been up much before 11 AM their time, especially after performing in concert the night before!!! Contrary to Mike’s accounting that they then recorded the song “a few days later,” Capitol Records Studio records show that The Beach Boys recorded ‘The Warmth of the Sun’ on January 1, 1964 … 40 days after the assassination … nearly six weeks after the song was first written. If Mike’s timeline can be off by 5 ½ weeks in this instance, the possibility certainly exists that it could be off by as much as 24 hours in the other instance.

 

A close-up of a document

Description automatically generated with medium confidence 

Courtesy of ALAN BOYD of CAPITOL RECORDS, here is a copy of the

ORIGINAL Union Contract for the Recording Session Held That Day

 

Acknowledging that after 44 years, memories fade (although it seems that anyone else who was alive that fateful day of November 22, 1963 remembers exactly where they were and what they were doing when they first heard the news of Kennedy’s death) ... as well as the possibility that oft-repeated "folklore" sometimes makes for a much more interesting "history" than accuracy ... we were willing to let things sit at a stand-off regarding this issue … even accepting the possibility that the song may have been started prior to hearing the news out of Dallas and then wrapped up sometime in the day (or days) following the event. But then we received some documentation from Beach Boys’ Friend and Promoter (and later Manager) Fred Vail who shed some very different light on this subject. Fred basically told us that, despite numerous reports and recollections to the contrary, Brian and Mike did not go into the office or the studio the night of or after the assassination to write ‘The Warmth of the Sun’ because, as you'll see in his “hands-on” report, they had a show to do that night!!! Fred was there with The Beach Boys that night ... the night of November 22, 1963, when, despite serious considerations to the contrary, they took the stage and performed a live concert in Marysville, California … and this is what he told us during our exclusive Forgotten Hits Interview earlier this year: 

 

KENT KOTAL: You’ve read the various versions surrounding the circumstances of November 22, 1963, as it relates to The Beach Boys’ classic ‘The Warmth Of The Sun’ … what are YOUR recollections of that day?

 

FRED VAIL: For me personally, November 22, 1963, started out like most other late fall days: school kids looking forward to the weekend off; mothers and fathers getting ready for Thanksgiving the following Thursday; retailers getting ready for the 'day after Thanksgiving' sales. Life was good.

 

KK: What was your relationship with The Beach Boys at the time ... you were working as their tour manager?
 

FV: I was not The Beach Boys 'tour manager' ... I was their concert promoter and 'advance man'. I would do a bit of 'marketing research' (although we certainly didn't call it that back then), checking out which cities were selling records and where the group was the most popular. Per my suggestion to Murry, we tended to do a lot of secondary markets, including Marysville, but also Fresno, Stockton, Reno, Boise, Salt Lake City and so on. Promoting our own shows, with Murry putting up the expense money, provided the guys with substantially more income, as opposed to only doing dates booked by the William Morris Agency, who represented them.

KK: But you had been booking "The Boys" for a while at this point, right?
 

FV: When I first booked the band for the May 24, 1963, concert at the Memorial Auditorium in Sacramento, I dealt with William Morris. That booking ended up being the first major 'headlining' concert for the group, and the only time I actually made MORE money than they did! :) I booked them for $750 flat, which included the group having to pay for six roundtrip airline tickets from LA. $750 was most likely the most money they had received up to that time, as they were getting $350 to $500 a night, working in teen clubs or as opening acts for other more established groups, including Jan & Dean and Dick Dale and The Del-Tones. At the time of the Marysville, CA 'dance and show' (which is what it was 'billed as' ... it's even advertised that way on the poster), they were probably getting about $1,500, perhaps, $2,000, per night. Again, since that particular gig was one of our own shows, they got the net receipts, after taking out the expenses Murry had 'fronted,' which probably amounted to $4,000 net for the night, substantially more than Morris was getting from promoters.

KK: Certainly the November 22nd gig had been booked sometime in advance ... no one could have known that there would have been anything significant about that date at the time.

 

FV: I was a nineteen year old college student and concert promoter -- the kid with the 'deejay voice.' It was just another work day for me: putting the finishing touches on my Beach Boys 'dance and show' that night, fifty miles north of Sacramento, in Marysville, California. The 'Boys' were the hottest American act ... just beginning their touring success but already secure having had their first Top 10 single, "Surfin' USA," the previous spring. "Surfer Girl" and "Little Deuce Coupe" had achieved equal chart success and "Be True To Your School" and "In My Room," which had been released in October, was already climbing the national charts. Our September 14 show at the Sacramento Memorial Auditorium had 'sold out' -- 5,200+ seats for the evening performance and nearly 2,000 for an afternoon 'pre-teeners' matinee. "Beach Dad," Murry Wilson, and I, had discussed doing a show in the agricultural communities of Marysville and Yuba City in an effort to hit some of the smaller secondary cities where radio spots and concert production costs were cheap and major acts seldom played those markets. So on that particular Friday morning I was up early, monitoring the local radio stations and getting ready to call the various ticket outlets to see how sales were going.

 

KK: Sounds like you took a pretty “hands on” approach to promoting your acts.

 

FV: There were no "Ticketmaster" and "Stub Hub" type operations in those days, ripping the artist, promoter and ticket buyer off in those days, we would typically get 100% of the face value of the ticket. The costs of setting up a concert in those days were substantially less than what they are now. I could rent auditoriums for $150 to $300, buy spots on the radio from $2 to $10, hire a local sound company, with operator, for $150. In some instances we'd have to pay a local box office manager a small commission, but a lot of communities didn't have central box offices, so I'd use local record shops and music stores, as was the case of my 'agreement' with Russ Solomon, founder of Tower Records. I would pay Russ $0.05 (five cents) for each ticket his store (Tower Records #1, Watt Avenue, Sacramento) sold. I made individual deals with area record stores and music shops who would sell my tickets in exchange for free advertising on our radio spots and posters. It was a 'win-win' for everyone. I was particularly fond of my relationship with KXOA Radio, one of two "Top 40" stations in Sacramento, the other being KROY. I had worked as a 'gopher' at KXOA during my freshman and sophomore year at El Camino High School, and in 1961 -- when they split their AM / FM simulcast and went 'county' on the FM side, I worked at the station as a deejay and program director. I was seventeen years old at the time. So, while most of our radio advertising had been on the local KUBA Radio in Yuba City, we had taken out a small schedule of spots on KXOA to 'hedge our bet,' so to speak -- knowing full well that a number of loyal Sacramento Beach Boys fans would also want to catch the 'boys' at the Marysville 'dance and show.' (Dancing was not allowed at our Sacramento Memorial Auditorium concerts).

 

KK: But then fate stepped in and pretty much stopped everybody in their tracks that day. How did you first hear about the shooting in Dallas? (I was in the third grade at the time … we had heard about the shooting that morning and, in those days, we still used to go home for lunch. When we returned to class, shortly after 1:00, our teacher, Mrs. Arnold, came in with this shocked look on her face that I can still see as clearly as if it were yesterday and announced, “President Kennedy is dead.”)

 

FV: I was out in one of the KXOA news cars with Johnny Gunn, one of the jocks, when we first heard of the tragic event in Dallas. Without hesitation, we headed back to the radio station. By the time we entered the lobby, the whole place was in chaos. Secretaries were crying, salesmen and others were waiting anxiously for the latest news reports. Most of the staff were already in the master control room, right off the newsroom, as the Associated Press and United Press International teletypes were chattering away with the latest news coming out of Dallas. Word came down shortly after 10 AM west coast time: President John F. Kennedy, our nation's youngest elected president, had been assassinated while his motorcade wound its way through the streets of Dallas, Texas, approaching Dealey Plaza. A stunned KXOA staff -- as well as a stunned world -- could not believe what they were hearing. "Camelot," the romantic name given to the new Kennedy Administration, had ended -- barely three years after it had begun.

 

KK: Obviously a tremendous shock to the system … at any age.

 

FV: I was saddened that this type of tragedy could take place in the United States. Political assassinations were something you read about in history books or saw on a news broadcast from some Third World country. It just didn't happen in the United States of America. However, I also had other things on my mind. What about the 'Boys' show in Marysville? Would the 'Beach Dad' still let the group perform that night?

 

KK: Certainly the first instinct must have been to call of the show … would anybody really expect The Beach Boys to perform on such a traumatic night?

 

FV: I hastily put in a call to Murry, who was just as much in shock as the rest of the world. "How can we play the show tonight, Fred," was his first question. I was eager to see the 'Boys' and just as eager to 'go on with the show,' but several questions lingered in my mind: would the city of Marysville allow us to go ahead with the concert? Would parents allow their kids to go out on such a tragic day? What about ticket sales? Would there be any backlash if we played the gig? I told Murry: "Let me make a few calls. It's still morning. We still have plenty of time for all of you to make the flight if we get a 'go ahead' from city officials and everything else checks out."

 

KK: And what was Murry Wilson’s reaction to that?

 

FV: Murry agreed to let me check out the situation and told me to get back to him within a couple of hours. So I immediately began calling the different parties connected with the show: the local Marysville / Yuba City radio stations, local record shops, the police, and city administrative offices. The city government, including police and parks and recreation, had no problem letting us go ahead with the show. The local radio stations had been flooded with calls about our appearance since the death of the President had been announced. Local ticket outlets were already doing a brisk business in sales as all the schools had been let out early. Everyone agreed: we could 'go on with the show.' I realized -- being a kid myself -- that most junior high school and high school aged students -- the 'core' audience of any Beach Boys concert -- would be excited about The Beach Boys coming to their town. It was not that they did not respect President Kennedy, nor the tragedy that had befallen our nation, it was that they were kids, it was the weekend, they'd waited a month the see their favorite "surfing band" and that was -- at that moment in time -- their priority. Also, there was not much else to do. All regular radio and television programming had been suspended. Recaps of the events of the day were played, replayed, and replayed again. Not too unlike a major story on CNN today! Most contemporary music stations either carried news reports or played only soft instrumental music out of respect to the president. Quite honestly, for kids -- particularly Beach Boys fans -- it was all pretty boring, to say the least.

 

KK: What happened next?

 

FV: I called Murry, passed along the information I'd compiled, and he said: "Are you sure this is okay?" I told him that I honestly felt we should go on with the show. He agreed, and we made plans for me to meet the plane at the old Sacramento Municipal Field. I borrowed my folks’ 1954 Chevy station wagon and got ready to pick up 'the Boys.' If I recall, they got in about 4:30 or 5:00 PM. We loaded all the gear into the back of the wagon, and along with one other car, driven by my dear friend and assistant, Mike Davidson, we headed toward Marysville. We did, however, stop long enough at the El Dorado Hotel in Sacramento for the group to check in and get freshened up from the flight. It made more sense to stay in Sacramento so that they'd be closer to the airport for the flight the next day. After a bit of a 'pit stop' we headed up to Marysville, less than an hour's drive away. We arrived at the Marysville Auditorium and headed backstage to see about setting up the gear. A local act, "Freddy and the Statics," were to open. We'd do a long set about 9:30 or so. The auditorium was set up for a 'dance and show' with folding chairs along the outer walls and a wide open wood floor for dancing. Much like the high school dances in the Boy's Gym that we all attended in our youth.

 

KK: What was the general mood of the crowd that night? Was anything mentioned about the events of the day prior to The Beach Boys taking the stage or did you just try to carry on with more of a “business as usual” attitude?

 

FV: When "Freddy and the Statics" completed their set, and the curtain went down, we immediately began setting up for the 'Boys' set. As always, I would introduce the group, but on this very special night, it was agreed that I would ask the audience for a 'moment of silence' in honor of our fallen President. I went out to the microphone, thanked the kids for coming, and asked them to be silent in tribute to the late President, John F. Kennedy. Since this was something none of us had ever done before, I didn't have any idea as to 'what amount of time' was appropriate for the audience to remain 'silent.' It seemed like hours standing out there, head bowed, while the audience was totally -- and respectfully -- quiet. All of a sudden, out of the corner of my eye as I glanced back at the curtain, I saw it shift a little, and I could see Mike's hand and face as he prepared to throw a towel at me! Just as it hit my back, I knew -- right then and there -- that it was time to bring on "The Beach Boys!"

 

KK: LOL … leave it to Mike to keep things moving, eh??? Was the crowd receptive? Were they able to put the events of the day aside for a few hours and enjoy the music and dancing?

 

FV: The show was a huge success. It not only broke the existing hall attendance record, but there were absolutely no incidents. The kids were well behaved and very, very grateful that their favorite "surfing band" had gone ahead with the show.

 

KK: And then what … after the show?

 

FV: I settled up with the box office manager, stuffing thousands of dollar bills and small change into grocery bags, which Murry and I carried to the cars. We headed back to the El Dorado Hotel, excited about the success of the evening's performance, but still very mindful of the tragic events that had happened just twelve or fourteen hours before in Dallas, Texas. It was probably about 1:00 AM when we got back to the rooms. Everyone 'doubled up' in those early days. No lavish suites. Sometimes there were three to a room. Murry and I dumped the bags of cash out on to one of the beds. I can vividly remember the bright turquoise bedspreads. The 'Boys' were amazed, perhaps, 'shocked,' to see all the cash sitting on the bed.

 

KK: Was that customary back then … to be paid out in cash like that after a performance?

 

FV: On a typical William Morris Agency contracted date, the local concert promoters would put up 50% of the 'guarantee' in advance, often writing a check the night of the performance for the other half. There were no 'percentage' type dates back then, or very, very few. So, seeing nearly $6,000 in 'cash,' was a bit unusual, even for The Beach Boys, as they were only getting $1,500 to $2,000 for their usual fee. However, this had not been a typical William Morris date. This had been a "Frederick Vail Production," a partnership (although not 50%) with Murry and the 'boys.'

 

KK: Having played in a band for many years (although never anything even remotely close to the level of crowds The Beach Boys were enjoying), I know that it’s often very difficult to “wind down” after a show like that … the adrenaline rush of seeing the crowd react in such a positive way … the music still ringing in your ears … sometimes it would take hours before you could stop replaying the night in your head and settle down and go to sleep.

 

FV: You’re right … it does take awhile. But as we all began to wind down from the events of the day, I looked over at Brian and Mike as they began working on a song that they'd already started earlier that morning. They were in the corner of the small room, still tightening up lyrics, working on the melody, and humming and singing a few lines here and a few lines there. By about 2 AM or so, the song was nearly complete. It would be a special musical tribute to our nation's 35th President, the youngest president ever elected, and also, the youngest to die in office. The song was "The Warmth of the Sun."

 

KK: So the song was not written prior to the evening of the assassination … and Mike and Brian did not go back to their “office” or the studio to work out the track.

 

FV: They had already been working on the melody and had a few of the lyrics written before we got back to the hotel. I’ve heard stories over the years about problems with Brian’s girlfriend or Mike’s girlfriend being part of the inspiration for the lyrics and this very well may have been true at the beginning of the writing process. But by the time they finished the song up that night, there was no question that the lyrics took on a more somber meaning as they related to the events in Dallas from earlier that day.

 

***

 

It would be interesting to get Brian Wilson, Mike Love and Fred Vail in a room together one day and see, once and for all, if rehashing this story between the three of them might, in fact, spark one or two more details … or refresh a memory here and there based on a collective accounting of the events of that day in November so long ago when an entire nation grieved. Until that happens, however, we’ve got to go along with “the most accurate truth” that we can reconstruct and take pride in knowing that even on the saddest of days, the music of The Beach Boys brought joy and happiness to their audience. It always has … and it always will.

 

***


Text

Description automatically generated

Courtesy of Fred Vail, here is a copy of the actual promotional poster for the concert that night ... November 22, 1963 ... at THE MARYSVILLE MEMORIAL AUDITORIUM


***


I asked Fred what he could tell us about the actual recording of the song "The Warmth Of The Sun" ... when (in proximity to writing it did they go into the studio to record it) and this is what he had to say: 

 

FRED VAIL: As to the 'recording' of "Warmth," after doing my own research and speaking to Alan Boyd, certainly one of the true 'authorities' on the group, as well as the guy who has put together a number of CD compilations for Capital Records, he feels comfortable with the Jan 1, 1964 date and found evidence to that effect on a union contract for that date.
(EDITOR'S NOTE: You can view the Union Contract / Studio Log for that session above.)

However, it was not unusual for Brian (or Capital) to combine songs on union contracts so that musicians could be paid quicker, and -- often -- the tracking sessions did not include the entire vocal overdub process, but we're going with the Jan 1 date.

I was at Western Recording on Jan 1, 1964 -- I'd been with the group at a New Years Eve gig at Bob Eubanks' Cinnamon Cinder Teen Club in San Bernardino the night before. The primary song on that recording date was "Fun, Fun, Fun," but "Warmth" was added to the session. Carl, Alan, Dennis, Mike and Brian all participated in the session, but there were 'wrecking crew' members there as well. I remember Hal Blaine (Drums) being there and I'm pretty sure that Steve Douglas and Jay Migliori (Sax) were also there, as was Ray Pohlman (bass).

 


© Copyright Kent Kotal / Forgotten Hits, 1998 - 2026 ... All rights reserved

NOTE:  This article was first published in Forgotten Hits in 2007; 

It was then later picked up and published in Endless Summer Quarterly, The Beach Boys / Brian Wilson fanzine edited by David Beard

FOR MORE STORIES BEHIND THE SONGS, CLICK ON THE "OLDER POSTS" BUTTON AT THE BOTTOM OF THIS PAGE

MORE STORIES BEHIND THE SONGS

The Story Behind ...  

 

SHANNON by HENRY GROSS:

The Story of "Shannon" (as told by Henry Gross):

When I was twenty-one years old a wonderful girl came into my life by the name of Kathy Reinmann. As if having her in my life as a friend, a wife and a friend again for the next twenty three years, until she died of lung cancer August 24, 1995, was not enough, she brought along with her into my heart her two year old Irish Setter, Shannon. She was an uncannily human dog whose ability to manipulate her human counterparts cannot be understated. I was touring around the country quite a lot in 1975 promoting an album called HENRY GROSS, the one with the yellow cover on A&M Records. I had the pleasure of doing long strings of dates with a group whose music always inspired me, The Beach Boys. Carl Wilson, arguably the finest solo voice in the group, was warm and welcoming from the very first show I played with them on a freezing cold day at the University of New Hampshire. After getting to know each other we realized we shared a love for much of the same music and a passion for fine vintage guitars. On a break from touring, while I was in Los Angeles, Carl invited me to his house to spend a day talking guitars, cars and rock & roll. While he was preparing lunch his two Alaskan husky dogs reached up on the counter and inhaled our food. I told Carl, while admiring the military perfection of the raid executed by his huskies, that I had an Irish Setter at home named Shannon. He was quite moved as he told me that he had an Irish Setter named Shannon that had been killed only recently when hit by a car. We spent the rest of the day jamming and driving around Carl's world which as a friend and to be honest a Beach Boy's fanatic was a thrill. When I returned to New York City, where I lived, I began work on my second A&M album, PLUG ME INTO SOMETHING. A few weeks later just as we were about to master the finished album I was sitting on my bed with Shannon strumming my guitar trying to write a song when I was disturbed by the loud bass sounds from the Latin music blasting from the apartment above me. Rather than complain I made an amazing discovery. If I tried to play records of my own choice I could drown out the intrusive bass sounds but was unable to concentrate. But I found that when I played an environments record called "The Ultimate Seashore" I could drown out the bass and have a pleasing and relaxing background sound that didn't interfere with my writing. In a matter of minutes with the ocean sounds guiding me, and my 1964 Gibson Hummingbird acoustic in my hands, my thoughts drifted to Carl, The Beach Boys and with a glance at my girl Shannon, the indescribable sadness that losing such a beloved partner in life must be. The song seemed to write itself taking no more than ten minutes and with almost no cross outs on the paper. I made a tape of it on my giant Sony cassette recorder and sent it off to Carl. I was hoping to stop the presses and record it for PLUG ME INTO SOMETHING which Carl had already sung on, adding background vocals to the opening song, ONE MORE TOMORROW, but it was too late. I had to wait for the next album to record it. I always wished I could have had Carl sing backgrounds on SHANNON but conflicting schedules dictated it wasn't meant to be. I believed after it was recorded for my RELEASE album, that it was destined to be a hit and lobbied hard for it to be the first single. You see, the man upstairs who had played the loud Latin music, beginning the entire chain of events, came down when he heard me playing mixes over and over to decide which I liked. However, rather than hearing the expected complaints, he said he loved the sound of the record and wanted to know where he could buy a copy. I reasoned if a salsa music fan who spoke little English loved the record through the ceiling, Shannon, Kathy and I had a hit on our hands. Fortunately, history and lady luck proved me right. And that is the true story of the song SHANNON.

FORGOTTEN HITS: The song that you are most famous for here in The States has got to be "Shannon" ... it's a beautiful tune and your website explains again what inspired you to write it. Once you knew that you were dedicating this song to Carl Wilson of The Beach Boys, did that help dictate the arrangement? The vocals are beautiful and I'm sure many folks at the time thought that perhaps The Beach Boys were actually singing on the record!

HENRY GROSS: I wrote the song without conscious effort to sound like anything. I more or less channeled it while thinking about a visit to Carl's Beverly Hills home I'd just had. I was always a big "Beach Boys" fan and I guess subconsciously I wrote in in their style. It took about ten minutes to write with almost no changes afterwards. One of those "meant to be's" I guess!


Stagger Lee

Stagger Lee (also recorded as both Stack-O-Lee and Stag-O-Lee) was first recorded in 1923 by blues / folk artist Mississippi John Hurt. The song tells the story of a murder that took place on Friday, December 27th (most often erroneously remembered as occurring on Christmas Eve) at The Bill Curtis Saloon in St. Louis, Missouri, back in 1895. According to legend, "Stag" Lee Shelton, a cab driver (and black pimp), shot and killed William "Billy" Lyons with his 44-caliber revolver after Billy snatched Stag's Stetson Hat. The story (as documented in The St. Louis Globe-Democrat in their issue dated Saturday Morning, December 28, 1895) read as follows:

"William Lyons, 25, colored, a levee hand, living at 1410 Morgan Street, was shot in the abdomen yesterday evening at 10 o'clock in the saloon of Bill Curtis, at Eleventh and Morgan Streets, by Lee Sheldon.  (NOTE spelling: Sheldon's CORRECT name was Shelton but it was misspelled throughout the newspaper article)  Sheldon, a carriage driver, also colored, lives at North Twelfth Street.

"Lyons and Sheldon were friends and were talking together. Both parties, it seems, had been drinking and were feeling in exuberant spirits. The discussion drifted to politics, and an argument was started, the conclusion of which was that Lyons snatched Sheldon's hat from his head. The latter indignantly demanded its return. Lyons refused, and Sheldon drew his revolver and shot Lyons in the abdomen. When his victim fell to the floor, Sheldon took his hat from the hand of the wounded man and coolly walked away.

"He was subsequently arrested and locked up at the Chestnut Street Station. Lyons was taken to the Dispensary, where his wounds were pronounced serious. He was removed to the city hospital. At the time of the shooting, the saloon was crowded with negroes. Lee Sheldon is also known as "Stag" Lee."

Lyons eventually died from the gun shot wounds inflicted that night. Shelton was tried and convicted and ultimately served prison time for the crime. In fact, he died in prison in 1912 of tuberculosis.

Although a total of five similar murders occurred that SAME day in St. Louis, for some reason the story of THIS murder spread and grew ... soon embellished and set to song. (Clearly, not only do you not tug on Superman's cape or spit in the wind or pull the mask of the ol' Lone Ranger ... but you ALSO do not mess around with Stag Lee's Hat!!!) In fact, Lee Shelton's "badness" grew at one point (according to Julius Lester's "Black Folktales") to near mythical proportions:

"Stagolee was, undoubtedly and without question, the baddest nigger that ever lived.
Stagolee was so bad that the flies wouldn't even fly around his head in the summertime, and the snow wouldn't fall on his house in the winter."

Most historians consider the Mississippi John Hurt version to be the most definitive, as it recounts most of the elements that eventually appeared in most of the musical retellings of the tale.

The first CHARTED version of Stagger Lee occurred in 1950 when an artist called simply Archibald hit The Top Ten on Billboard's Rhythm and Blues Chart. This was the first time the common melody associated with this tune came into our consciousness.

Nine years later, Lloyd Price would top both Billboard's R & B Chart as well as their Pop Chart with his rendering. The biggest hit version came in 1959 when Lloyd Price took his rocked-up version all the way to #1 on The Billboard Chart.

DIDJAKNOW? - 1: Dick Clark was so concerned about the song's description of a murder that he had Price cut another version for airing on American Bandstand!!!
He needn't have worried ... it was the original, unedited "scary" version that topped the charts!!!

DIDJAKNOW? - 2: Lloyd's cousin was a guy named Larry Williams, who also served as Price's driver and valet. When he, too, got interested in music, Lloyd got him an audition with Specialty Records, where he recorded the '50's rock and roll classics Short Fat Fannie and Bony Moronie. The Beatles (and John Lennon in particular!) thought enough of Larry's recordings to record their own versions of Dizzy Miss Lizzy, Slow Down and Bad Boy.

DIDJAKNOW? - 3: The background singers on Lloyd Price's version of Stagger Lee were none other than The Ray Charles Singers, a move Price says was calculated to help him cross-over to a white record-buying audience.
(P.S. It worked!!!)

In 1967, The Wicked Wilson Pickett cut a GREAT soulful version that went all the way to #17 on The Cash Box Chart. (It remains yet ANOTHER Top 20 Hit COMPLETELY ignored by oldies radio today ... and that's a shame because it's a GREAT version!!!)

And, in 1971, bubblegum star Tommy Roe cut probably the most "vanilla" rendition ever committed to vinyl. 


Over the years, versions of Stagger Lee were recorded by artists as diverse as Beck, Pat Boone, James Brown, Nick Cave and the Bad Seeds, The Clash, Neil Diamond, Dion, Fats Domino, Dr. John, Bob Dylan, Duke Ellington, The Fabulous Thunderbirds, The Grateful Dead, Woody Guthrie, Bill Haley and the Comets, The Isley Brothers, Tom Jones, Huey Lewis and the News, Jerry Lee Lewis, Memphis Slim, Elvis Presley, Professor Longhair, Ma Rainey, The Righteous Brothers, Tom Rush, Taj Mahal, Ike and Tina Turner, The Ventures and Doc Watson ... as well as literally HUNDREDS of others! Yesterday we featured a couple of the earliest known recordings, including a 1923 reading by Mississippi John Hurt and the first CHARTED version by Archibald, a Top Ten Hit on Billboard's Rhythm and Blues Chart back in 1950.

And the legend of Stagger Lee lives on ... in his song Shoulder Holster from his Blue Moves album, Elton John sings "It was just like Frankie and Johnny ... and it was just like Stagger Lee" ... in the recent film Black Snake Moan, actor Samuel L. Jackson's character sings a little bit of the song. And, although we kidded about it yesterday, I've just GOT to believe that Jim Croce was at least in SOME way inspired by the escapades of Stagger Lee when he wrote his #1 Hits You Don't Mess Around With Jim and Bad, Bad Leroy Brown. Suffice to say, Stagger Lee's fame was widespread and legendary.

Wanna do MORE research on this tune??? You'll find ALL kinds of referrals for Stagger Lee on the web ... just google that title and nearly 100,000 references will pop up!!!

In fact, it's now speculated that part of the reason the story of Stagger Lee
spread as quickly (and as widely) as it did was due to a song called The Bully Song first featured in the Broadway Musical The Widow Jones back in 1895, about three months BEFORE the murder of Billy Lyons took place at Bill Curtis' Saloon.
In those original lyrics, we're warned:

"Have you heard about that Bully that just came to town?
He's down among the niggers, layin' their bodies down.
I'm a-lookin' for that bully and he must be found."

It's believed by some that Stagger Lee's name was later inserted as the source of some of the nasty deeds performed by The Bully ... and that as the legend grew, more and more evilness was attributed to The Stag Man over time.

Meanwhile, with literally HUNDREDS of recorded versions of the song in existence, Stagger Lee's reputation for "badness" grew over the years ... so much so that in one version, Stagger Lee appears in hell after he is executed and is SO bad that he takes control of The Devil's Kingdom!!!

Rolling Stone Magazine (when naming Stagger Lee one of the 500 Greatest and Most Influential Rock And Roll Songs Of All-Time) referred to Stagger Lee as "the original gangsta"!!! I think they just may be right!


Hot Rod Lincoln

It all started innocently enough ... during our very first Local Hits Series, we were spotlighting the #1 Chicagoland Hit, Shortnin' Bread, by Paul Chaplain.  In that piece, we ran a copy of the very first WLS Silver Dollar Survey ever issued ... and after they saw it, several folks on the list wrote in to say that they were surprised to see the song Hot Rod Lincoln in the Top Ten by a guy named Johnny Bond ... apparently, many of you were not aware that this was a hit record prior to the Commander Cody version from 1972.  Before we knew it, we had received quite a bit of mail surrounding a musical piece that was NOT even the song that was being featured ... so we thought we'd give you just a little bit of history here!


Hot Rod Lincoln actually charted for TWO different artists in 1960 ... Johnny Bond took his version to #26 in Billboard, #25 in Cash Box and #7 here in Chicago on the WLS Chart ... and a guy named Charlie Ryan ALSO released a version in 1960, which went to #33 in Billboard, shared the #25 position in Cash Box (as many versions of the same song did back then) and hit #16 here in Chicago.  (Forgive the pun, but they literally RACED each other up the charts!)

Further research showed that the song went back as far as 1951, when it charted by Tiny Hill as Hot Rod Race.  (We got this information from the Joel Whitburn book.)  But then we got THIS message from Ed Parker (aka JacoFan):

Actually Arkie Shibley did "Hot Rod Race" in 1950.  I got it from Napster and included it on my history of rock'n'roll compilation CD.  Steve Propes and Jim Dawson picked it as one of the 50 candidates for "the first rock'n'roll record," saying it inspired a "whole parking lot of similar songs".

So that NEW piece of information got us digging even DEEPER!!! 

We found a website run by a guy named Joe Wajgel that'll tell you more about the history of Hot Rod Lincoln than you could ever possibly want to know.  Hot Rod Race (as it was originally called back in 1950 / 1951) was written by a guy named George Wilson.  (Not much is known about old George other than the fact that he used to be Dennis The Menace's next-door neightbor ... j/k!!!)  It was, in fact, first recorded by Arkie Shibley, just as Ed had told us.  As a matter of fact, four different versions charted on the various Billboard charts in 1951:  Shibley's version hit #5 on the Country Chart, the aforementioned Tiny Hill version peaked at #29 on the Pop Chart ... which is probably why Whitburn referred to THAT one in his Top Pop Singles book (and hit #7 on the Country Chart), Ramblin' Jimmie Dolan ALSO hit #7 on the Country Chart, as did country legend Red Foley with HIS version of Hot Rod Race.  In addition, at least two or three OTHER versions were released that year which did NOT make the charts!

Johnny Bond would go on to have one other Top 40 Hit ... the novelty song Ten Little Bottles  hit #34 in Cash Box Magazine in 1965.  In between, he worked for Gene Autry and appeared in over 50 movies!

Charlie Ryan, on the other hand, tried to make an entire career out of this one hit.  He first recorded a version of Hot Rod Lincoln (considered an "answer song" at the time) in 1955.  It was re-recorded (and re-released) late in 1959, several months before the more popular Johnny Bond version.  (Ironically, both 1960 versions credit Ryan as the songwriter along with W.S. Stevenson).  Ryan's follow-up singles included Hot Rod Race (his version of the Arkie Shibley original, released in 1961), Hot Rod Lincoln Drags Again (from 1964), Hot Rod Hades, Burlington Chase, Side Car Cycle, Hot Rod Harley, I Married The Gal With The Cycle, The Dart And The Lincoln and Hot Rod Rocket.


Click here: Hot Rod Lincoln, The Song / A Short History 

BTW:  Very special thanks to RSMLITHO, THE ONE BUFF and JACOFAN for their help in supplying wavs and information, which helped us to prepare for the original Hot Rod Lincoln / Forgotten Hits mini-series!  

Hot-Rodding has always been one of those 1950's rock-and-roll / juvenille delinquent stereotypes ... at least that seems to be the era that's locked in time with this image.  However, the fact is as soon as there were automobiles, there were people out there trying to make those automobiles go faster.

According to Joe Wajgel, the first hit song about a car was recorded back in 1905 by Billy Murray (no, not the Saturday Night Live Guy!!!), who took In My Merry Oldsmobile all the way to #1, where it stayed for seven weeks.  Literally hundreds and hundreds of car songs have followed it.  (The Beach Boys, Jan and Dean, Ronny and the Daytonas and several others owe a HUGE debt to this fad!)  And let's not forget Rocket 88, felt my many to be the very first rock and roll song ever!!!

Although this seems to be more of a late-'50's thing, Hot Rod Magazine was first published back in 1947 and the song Hot Rod Race ... which evolved into the better-known Hot Rod Lincoln ... first hit the charts in late 1950 / early 1951. 

We stated at the time that this piece originally ran that Joel Whitburn's book should probably be revised to say that the first POP charting of this song was by Tiny Hill back in 1951.  It peaked at #29 on the pop charts that year.

Arkie Shibley's version never hit the pop chart, but peaked at #5 on the Country Chart in 1950.  He was actually the FIRST to record this track.  In fact, after recording the George Wilson original, he wrote several follow-ups:  Hot Rod Race #2 was released in 1951, Arkie Meets The Judge (aka Hot Rod Race #3) followed it, as did Hot Rod Race #4 (aka The Guy In The Mercury) and Hot Rod Race #5 (The Kid In The Model "A").

The most popular version ever recorded of Hot Rod Lincoln was done in 1972 by Commander Cody and His Lost Planet Airmen.  They took THEIR version all the way to #2 here in Chicago ... and scored a Top Ten smash all the way around, peaking at #7 in Cash Box and #9 in Billboard. 


But the legend doesn't stop there ... more recent versions by country artists Asleep At The Wheel and even comedian Jim Varney (Ernest of "Hey Vern" fame), who recorded it for the soundtrack of the motion picture version of The Beverly Hillbillies, have kept the song alive for over 50 years.

For a complete history of the song, the legend and the legacy, check out this website:
Click here: Hot Rod Lincoln, The Song / A Short History

It'll tell you more than you EVER needed to know!!!

BTW:  Shibley's version of Hot Rod Race 

contains the politically incorrect line "We were rippin' along like white folks might," which probably had a lot more impact on the southern country stations in 1950 than it does today.  We have to remember that this truly was a different time and place!

 

© Copyright Kent Kotal / Forgotten Hits, 1998 - 2026 ... All rights reserved

 

FOR MORE STORIES BEHIND THE SONGS, CLICK ON THE "OLDER POSTS" LINK BELOW 

THE STORIES BEHIND THE SONGS

The True Story Behind THE BEACH BOYS'Classic Song " THE WARMTH OF THE SUN "   Some forty years from now, our children will p...